Read more from Dean: https://www.vice.com/en_us/contributor/dave-dean
Follow Dean on Twitter: @ddner
Originally published at VICE
|It is speculated that many children have been forcibly circumcised over the past 7 decades in Canada and the United States.|
In 2006, Paul Tinari was granted $12,000 by the government of British Columbia to have foreskin restoration surgery. When he was eight years old and boarded at a church-run school in Montreal, Paul was forcefully held down on a desk and circumcised, because a priest had reason to believe Paul had—God forbid—masturbated.
Paul is Métis, and his story is another seriously disturbing instance of church abuse in the era of residential schools. Paul claims the practice was routine, and could have happened to thousands of young First Nations boys trapped in the system—though that is impossible to confirm, especially given the Canadian government’s lack of transparency regarding the residential schools issue. We talked to Paul over the phone about what he went through, why it may have occurred, and his outspoken opinions in support of the intactivist movement.
Can you tell me what happened to you?
Sure. My mother was widowed very young, so she put me into this boarding school in Outremont, in Montreal. It was run by the church. It was actually a convent, but the priests had access to it. Now it turns out, I read many years later, that one of the nuns made a formal complaint she was getting regularly raped by the priests. So when I heard that story, I decided to come forward with my story that I’d kept hidden for all these years. That was the impetus that got me to go public with my story.
Your circumcision took place in Montreal?
Yes. Essentially what happened was there was another boy there who didn’t like me at all so he decided to set me up. He told one of the priests he’d seen me masturbating. And this was a known evil -- something you should never do. It wasn’t true, but he told the priest that.
You were only eight years old?
I was about eight, yes. I didn’t know anything about masturbating. I was totally innocent. Anyway, so late, late one night—we slept in a big dormitory with all the other boys—the priest came in and really roughly pulled me out of bed. He brought me down the stairs, he brought me down the hall, and he brought me to this room where there was this bearded guy. I didn’t know what was going on. It took me a long time to figure out what role these people played. It turns out that the guy with the beard who was wearing a beanie and a black suit was a mohel, a Jewish circumciser.
They pulled my pajamas down and then tried to pin me down to the desk, but of course it’s easier to do that to a baby than an eight year old. I fought back. I kicked one of the priests who was holding me down in the nose, and their response to that was to actually break my arm and break my nose. So I had a broken arm and a broken nose—which I still have to this day. He pinned me down, the guy put a clamp on my penis, and they performed the circumcision right there on the desk with no anaesthetic, no disinfectant, no nothing.
So as a result of this I had very serious infections for many, many weeks and months afterwards. Matter of fact, I had a chronic infection for the rest of my life until I had corrective surgery. He took so much skin off that I wasn’t able to have an erection without great pain.
Yeah. It was horrible. That’s how I went through my life until my 40s, when I had corrective surgery. I’m one of the few people who’s qualified to speak to what’s it like to be intact, then circumcised, then intact again. For any man who’s circumcised and says there’s no difference, he doesn’t know what the hell he’s talking about. Since I’ve had restoration surgery my sex life has improved 1,000 percent. There’s no comparison. It’s like going from black and white vision to color vision.
|Lost/Found Educational Cards at Etsy|
The Catholic Church—in Montreal in particular—has a history of withholding documents, pertaining to their role in the residential school system, from the Truth and Reconcilliation Commission. Do you think this kind of punishment was being done on a broader scale? You must not have been the only one.
I was told that if I told anybody or if I talked to any of those boys that I would go to hell, and in those days I believed that. But I do believe that several of the other boys were treated the same way even though we never discussed it among ourselves. We were in fear. I don’t know if you know what it’s like to live in total fear every day.
And the people who did this to you, do you think they believed in the religiosity of it? Did they think they were really doing God’s good work, or was this based in something more sadistic?
What you have to do is go back to the Middle Ages and look at the witch burnings. It’s hard for us in our present, modern world to get into the mindset that existed at that time, but you have to realize that the witch burnings were not an act of hate. They were an act of love. The compassion for the person, because they considered the body the mortal flesh to be disposable, and all that mattered was saving a person’s soul.
So if these guys thought they were doing right—the priest and the mohel—do you think they should be held criminally responsible?
Of course. Regardless of their religious beliefs. I was an underage minor, and my mother never gave consent, and I didn’t give consent. So today, we teach kids to say no to adults who are touching them inappropriately, right? Well, I said no, and no one listened.
|What makes genital cutting not assault? Consent.|
Can you get into the industry of circumcision a bit?
If there was no profit to be made in circumcision it would have been abandoned long ago. But Dr. Kellogg [the man who invented Corn Flakes because he thought "bland foods" could "curb passions" and allegedly thought circumcision could "cure" masturbation] realized he was making a fortune circumcising children—the parents were paying him to circumcise their children to prevent masturbation. Basically, all the original doctors to perform circumcisions in the United States were trained by Dr. Kellogg. And you’ve got to realize he knew what he was doing. He was inducing sexual dysfunction because not only did he think that masturbation was evil, but he also thought that sex itself was degrading. He advocated celibacy that sex was unhealthy as something evil, so he believed that rendering the penis dysfunctional was a good thing.
[See: Circumcision: A Brief History in Physicians' Own Words || Circumcision to Reduce Men's Pleasure]
|Circumcision Profit Flow Chart|
Do you have any idea if he was circumcised?
No idea. He probably circumcised himself. The guy was crazy enough to do that. So anyway, the industry grew up and discovered that foreskin is highly useful stuff. There’s a multi-billion dollar industry driving continued circumcision.
What kind of products are we talking about? It’s blowing my mind that there’s a commercial market for foreskin.
Foreskin obtained from circumcisions are used by biochemical and anatomical researchers to study skin. It’s used to make skin for burn patients, for skin grafts. It’s used for anti-aging skin cream. It goes on and on. There’s one doctor in Vancouver who boasts about having performed over 35,000 circumcisions and he’s charging about $200-$400 at a time [it can be up to $1,000 in Ontario]. Do the math about how much he’s earned. He’s earned millions.
[See: Neonatal Foreskin Used in doTERRA Research || Sandra Bullock on Foreskin Facial Cream || German Factory Uses Foreskin to Grow New Skin || Is Foreskin the New Botox? || Stealing Foreskin: The Science of Skin Grafting || The Foreskin in Oprah's Face Cream || Foreskin Sale! Online Listing]
|Informational Postcards for Education available at Etsy|
In her 2006 report, Amanda Euringer expanded previously on Dr. Tinari's case:
This past April, Vancouver resident Dr. Paul Tinari became the first Canadian man to have a heath-care-funded foreskin restoration. When he was eight years old, doctors at his school performed an operation without his consent. After years of painful erections, and frequent infections, Dr. Tinari -- with the support of his doctor and psychiatrist -- successfully sued, and as a result, the B.C. Ministry of Health paid for 90 per cent of the $12,000 operation.
Dr. Tinari says he hopes that it will set a precedent for legal action that will eventually end the practice of infant circumcision all together. Dr. Tinari, an engineer, considers himself uniquely authorized to discuss the subject of circumcision. “I was uncircumcised until I was eight, then circumcised until I was 48, and am now again uncircumcised, so I really have seen all sides of this issue.”
Tinari, a Metis, describes being held down and circumcised as a young boy in what he says was “a routine form of punishment” for masturbation at residential schools. He claims that thousands of young native and Metis boys were circumcised during their stays in the residential school system. Dr. Tinari’s case and his efforts to bring awareness to the issue are the most recent installments in a movement against what the medical establishment calls routine, non-therapeutic male circumcision.
North America has the highest rates in the world for this procedure, but currently, no regional, national or international medical body in the western world advocates its practice. In fact, many, like the College of Physicians and Surgeons of B.C., recommend against it. Historically, many doctors performed circumcision believing there were psychological and medical benefits, but pro-intact advocates say that since these medical benefits have now been disproved, the issue is one of cruelty. Dr. Tinari says his intention is to rectify what he sees as “human rights abuse” and a “gross violation” of a small child’s body.
|Who in the world is circumcised? Percentage of men who are not intact per World Health Organization statistics.|
Dr. Paul D. Tinari: The Brain Permanently Altered from Infant Circumcision (Canadian study)
Circumcision Study Ends Early Due to Infant Trauma (Canadian study)
Effectiveness of Anesthesia for Circumcision Pain
The Circumcision Secret: My Experience (Man from Wisconsin speaks)
My Story of Ritual Abuse (Jewish man speaks)
Saving Our Sons Community Group || Public Saving Our Sons Page on Facebook
Medical Professionals for Genital Autonomy
|Dr. Paul Tinari went on to be witness to one study at Queen's University that addressed the impact of genital cutting on the human brain.|